Welcome to Toys on the Square - Unusual Toys & Gifts

Check out a few of our newest toys!

**Please note** Online orders placed on or after 3/1/25 will not be shipped until 3/5. Sorry for the inconvenience while we attend Toy Fair in NYC searching for the newest and best toys to bring you joy! The store is still open so stop by!

Arrow Head Paint Horse

$1199

Local Pick Up and Shipping

Enjoy the convenience of local pickup or delivery with our online store.

As sure footed and determined as they come, let Arrow Head the courageous plush Paint Horse lead the way on the next trail ride! This hardy Indian pony knows all the best paths over the rocky ground. A lively expression and stand up pose will make him a favorite when it’s time for imaginative play. His spotted pinto pattern is crafted with cuddly brown and white plush fur that’s squeezably soft. Arrow Head’s playful, coltish look can be attributed to his fluffy, chestnut colored mane and tail. An enticing Western adventure awaits! When it can be shared with a friend as gallant as this hardy Paint Horse stuffed animal, you won’t want to let it pass you by!

Payment & Security

Payment methods

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

Your payment information is processed securely. We do not store credit card details nor have access to your credit card information.