Skip to content

Welcome to Toys on the Square - Unusual Toys & Gifts

Check out a few of our newest toys!

Visit Us Store Hours

Search

Menu

Home
Shop by Interests
About Us
Help
Contact Us

Call Us

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Spring is coming!

Home
Plush

Plush

(381 products)

Sort by

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

View as List Grid

FiltersFilter & Sort

Applied Filters

Clear all

Sort by

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Availability

In stock (379)
Out of stock (2)

Clear

Price

From $

-

To $

From To

Clear

Collection

Plush (381)

Clear

Brand

Clear

Squishable
Squishable Plague Nurse

$51⁹⁹

View details
Douglas
Starsky Appaloosa Horse

$24⁹⁹

View details
Douglas
Sugar Queen Bee

$19⁹⁹

View details
Sale
Douglas
Super Fernie Soft Fawn

$34⁹⁹ ~~$39⁹⁹~~

View details
Wild Republic
Sweet & Sassy Snake Polka Dot

$24⁹⁹

View details
Douglas
Swiftie Squirrel Soft

$21⁹⁹

View details
Ty - Beanie Babies
Tabor 6" TY

$6⁹⁹

View details
Douglas
Tandy Rainbow Unicorn

$14⁹⁹

View details
Tasty Peach Studios
Tasty Peach® - 7" Electric Blue Meowchi

$13⁹⁹

View details
Gund
Teach Me Cookie Monster, 15 in

$34⁹⁹

View details
Gund
Tilly the Monkey, 15in

$29⁹⁹

View details
Ty - Beanie Bellies
Tink 6" TY

$6⁹⁹

View details
Marvel
TY Marvel Black Panther

$7⁹⁹

View details
TY
TY Iron Man

$7⁹⁹

View details
TY
TY Jamal Camel 6"

$6⁹⁹

View details
TY
WILFRED - dog gray 6"

$6⁹⁹

View details
Douglas
Winnie White Cat Soft

$22⁹⁹

View details
Gund
Xavier Kitten, 9 in

$29⁹⁹

View details
Douglas
Yettie Yorkie

$21⁹⁹

View details
Gund
Zi-Bo 17in

$34⁹⁹

View details
Ty - Beanie Balls
ZINGER - bee yellow ball

$4⁹⁹

View details

Previous
Page 16 / 16
1
…
14
15
16
Next

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Subtotal:$0⁰⁰ USD

Loading...

Toys on the Square is a brick-and-mortar store located just outside of Hershey, PA. We offer a wide variety of hand-selected toys for all ages.

17 W Main St
Hummelstown, PA 17036

Store Hours

Facebook
Instagram
Twitter

Quick Links

My Account
About Us
Help
Contact Us
Search

Policies

Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Shipping Policy
Contact Information

Newsletter

Sign up for exclusive offers, original stories, events and more.

Email

Payment methods accepted

© 2025 Toys on the Square. Powered by Shopify | Energized by Specialty Toys Network

Choose options

Item added to your cart.

View cart